Anyone have flat & domed IR filters?

Discuss specialist military equipment i.e. Night Vision Goggles, Magellan GPS, Special Forces Kit, Abseil equipment, Diving and Aquatic gear etc
Post Reply
User avatar
fv1620
Bake Off Judge
Posts: 2268
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:16 pm
Location: GB-CMN (formerly UK91)
Contact:

Anyone have flat & domed IR filters?

Post by fv1620 » Wed Mar 20, 2019 2:25 pm

Wondering if someone could help me with a bit research if they have both types of IR filter (ie flat & domed)

Ideally to fit one of each type on the headlights, assuming these have standard incandescent light bulbs, not halogen or LED even. Then in darkness with IR lighting on, assess the amount of visible red light that can be seen, to see if one type emits more visible red than the other or whether the amounts are equal.

I think it would be preferable to test them simultaneously then it will allow the same degree of accommodation to darkness for a particular operator's eyes. It would be best to wait several minutes in darkness before the test to wait for some night accommodation.

On completion of the test it would be interesting to feel the heat generated on each filter to see if they are equal or not.

Please do not stare into the IR beam as although you will not see it, that IR energy will be dissipated in the eyeball. In the same way that you would not stare into a normal headlight.

Many thanks to whom ever might undertake this research for the enlightenment of all.

Having just given a talk on WW2 IR to our local amateur radio club, preparing it with a lot of new material has been quite illuminating & reignited my interest in the subject.

I trawled ebay to see the state IR/Tabby equipment for sale & have to say there are loads of adverts making misleading, extraordinary & unfounded claims that their items were rare prototypes/SOE/SAS etc & various convoluted conjectures. I contacted three sellers politely giving them details of what they were actually offering. Two haven't replied, but one was very grateful & has changed the advert. She was so pleased that she has offered me first pick of the stock of military items & a request for suggested valuations. If this happens I will do my best to be fair about it, not just because it is the right thing to do but you never know what might crop up later & as buyer/advisor with a proven track record it should stand me in good stead.
Clive Elliott

Collecting military technical publications, researching into military vehicle electrical systems, licensed radio amateur since 1964 using microwave bands for tropospheric scatter.

User avatar
Bob Fell
Cake Guru
Posts: 3044
Joined: Wed Sep 18, 2013 7:17 am
Location: Melton Mowbray

Re: Anyone have flat & domed IR filters?

Post by Bob Fell » Wed Mar 20, 2019 6:22 pm

Hi Clive,
My vehicle has the BPF bulbs and FV lenses but regrettably I only have the flat IRR filters so cannot help.
I think Sidders has both types but don't know what headlights he is running with.
Regards
Bob
042Bobf


19HF27 Lightweight FFR ex Gurkha Field Force HQ, various Gurkha Sigs Tps and Comp Ord Depot Hong Kong 1980-1997.
42ET39 Narrow Track Sankey ex BAOR 22 & 7 Sig Regts, 16/5 Lancers, 2 RTR, 9/12 Lancers & QDG 1969-2001.

User avatar
Sidders101
Bake Off Judge
Posts: 2406
Joined: Wed Apr 02, 2014 7:57 pm
Location: Winchester

Re: Anyone have flat & domed IR filters?

Post by Sidders101 » Wed Mar 20, 2019 8:21 pm

Hi Clive..I have both types of lenses and a working set of Infrared reciever binoculars...if you wish I can bring all to Overlord for you to test at your leisure.,..
Sidders


1974 Series 3 LWT 12v RHD 69-FM-24 , Royal Marines ("Intrepid")
1976 101 forward control gun tractor 12v RHD- 73-FL-43 ex 1,2 & 3 Para ("Kryten")
1979 Sankey NT Trailer 06-HF-86 78 Engr Reg (Herman)
1978 Trophy Frank Spencer impression (1st place)

User avatar
fv1620
Bake Off Judge
Posts: 2268
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:16 pm
Location: GB-CMN (formerly UK91)
Contact:

Re: Anyone have flat & domed IR filters?

Post by fv1620 » Wed Mar 20, 2019 10:38 pm

Sid that would be good. Yes so please bring to Overload.

I have some CVRT ones which are very dark & allow very little red light through. My recollection of the WW2 IR lamp I had (no clip on filters they were dedicated IR use only) was that there was a fair bit of visible red coming through. This was deliberate so that it increased the sensitivity of the viewer yet this spillage of red light could not be seen far away.

I had both flat & domed types but at different times. I did night driving once with the domed ones & can remember being able to just make out the pattern of the filament. The flat ones I never tried as I fitted them on the Hornet & donated them to keep it complete when I returned the Hornet to the Tank Museum.

Someone recently was asking me why the Germans were so advanced with night vision fighting, why weren't they so advanced with night driving? We all hear about the Tigers, Panthers & that stuff that modellers love to reproduce & the public travel great distances to see at Bovington. Well despite all this technology they did lose the war & most supply logistics was far from technological.

Of the 322 German divisions in 1943 only 52 were mechanised or motorised. During WW2 the Germans used a total of 2.7 million horses.

Horses can cope with darkness very well & this was demonstrated in WW1 as after dark supplies moved by MT was far more likely to come to grief than horse-drawn supplies.
Clive Elliott

Collecting military technical publications, researching into military vehicle electrical systems, licensed radio amateur since 1964 using microwave bands for tropospheric scatter.

User avatar
Sidders101
Bake Off Judge
Posts: 2406
Joined: Wed Apr 02, 2014 7:57 pm
Location: Winchester

Re: Anyone have flat & domed IR filters?

Post by Sidders101 » Thu Mar 21, 2019 5:48 am

It always baffled me why the British Army used this IR system and presumably spent a lot of money developing it...when it only requires the enemy to have a similar system in order to "see" our night manoeuvres, thus rendering it useless..??
Sidders


1974 Series 3 LWT 12v RHD 69-FM-24 , Royal Marines ("Intrepid")
1976 101 forward control gun tractor 12v RHD- 73-FL-43 ex 1,2 & 3 Para ("Kryten")
1979 Sankey NT Trailer 06-HF-86 78 Engr Reg (Herman)
1978 Trophy Frank Spencer impression (1st place)

User avatar
fv1620
Bake Off Judge
Posts: 2268
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:16 pm
Location: GB-CMN (formerly UK91)
Contact:

Re: Anyone have flat & domed IR filters?

Post by fv1620 » Thu Mar 21, 2019 8:13 am

Yes but we can also see them.

If we had no IR system then the enemy could use theirs & move around more readily in darkness with impunity.
Clive Elliott

Collecting military technical publications, researching into military vehicle electrical systems, licensed radio amateur since 1964 using microwave bands for tropospheric scatter.

User avatar
fv1620
Bake Off Judge
Posts: 2268
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:16 pm
Location: GB-CMN (formerly UK91)
Contact:

Re: Anyone have flat & domed IR filters?

Post by fv1620 » Thu Mar 21, 2019 8:52 am

PS Most of the money, time & effort was expended in WW2 when 100,000 image converter tubes were made for fitting in IR systems to a wide range of armoured & non-armoured vehicles. It would have given us the upper hand as the Germans only had limited IR facilities seeing IR as a means of night fighting rather than night driving. Particularly as much of their logistical support was with horses. There were only three IR equipped units Kamfgruppe Uhu fighting on the Eastern Front with massive IR searchlights often needing 8kW generators. The Germans were not geared up to mass produce small IR systems as their various types of IR tube required a set of strange voltages & more complicated optics.

They didn't start taking IR night driving seriously until 1943 when the tide started to turn as previously they had managed fine without such equipment. Besides German commanders had a naive attitude as they didn't want IR binoculars fitted unless they could work in daylight. For night driving you need no magnification quite different optical demands to using binoculars in daylight. In fact the Germans had no IR binoculars at all, they were all monocular based.

By 1943 we were manufacturing 3,000 IR sets of which 2,000 were for fitting to tanks. There is no recorded use of any IR system by the British Army in WW2, yet Churchill wanted them to be used in all theatres simultaneously. A lost opportunity indeed.
NVGa.jpg
NVGa.jpg (155.9 KiB) Viewed 13460 times
Clive Elliott

Collecting military technical publications, researching into military vehicle electrical systems, licensed radio amateur since 1964 using microwave bands for tropospheric scatter.

Post Reply